Skip to Main Content

WRIT 3307: Advanced Writing: Evaluating Information Sources

Resources for Advanced Writing

Introduction

In general, information sources tend to be categorized as:

  • popular or scholarly/academic, based primarily on content level, intended audience, and the rigor of the pre-publication review/editing process
  • primary, secondary, or tertiary, based on immediacy of the author or creator to the content/event

Open Internet & Social Media Information Sources

Anyone can publish material online through blog/web services or social media. Such writing or commentary is well suited to quick communication and often includes brief postings on topics of conversation between the author and reader. Some columnists and writers for traditional publications also publish blogs to extend their interaction with readers. Remember to ask yourself:

  • Who is this author?
  • Does he/she have relevant expertise and experience on the topic at issue?
  • Are his/her claims adequately supported?

See The Open Internet tab for more information.

Types of Information Sources

There are many types of information sources. The following table contains traditional source types often used in college-level assignments:

 

News Sources

Popular Magazines

Trade Journals

Scholarly Journals

Academic Books

Purpose

Inform about current events and topics.

Provide basic facts and details.

Inform and/or entertain about current or recent events and topics.

Inform and report on news, trends, and issues relevant to an industry or profession.

Inform and report on research done by scholars and experts.

Cover specialized academic topics.

Provide a thorough, comprehensive examination of academic topics.

Author

Journalists, freelance writers, or editorial staff.

Brief editing process.

Journalists, freelance writers, or editorial staff

Brief editing process.

Journalists, freelance writers, editorial staff, or industry practitioners.

Brief editing process.

Subject specialists and experts.

Extensive editing process.

Usually peer-reviewed.*

Subject specialists and experts.

Extensive editing process.

Audience

Anyone.

Appeals to non-specialists.

Anyone

Appeals to non-specialists.

Those who work in a particular field or profession.

Researchers, scholars, and higher education students.

Researchers, scholars, and higher education students.

Other Characteristics

Brief, published and/or updated daily.

Often a good source for editorials or opinion pieces.

Short or medium-length articles.

Published weekly or monthly.

Often a good source for features, opinion pieces, and interviews.

Usually short or medium-length articles.

May include brief reference lists or works cited.

Usually published monthly.

Specialized and lengthy articles.

Include reference lists or works cited.

Takes months to publish due to extensive editing process; often published quarterly.

Include reference lists or works cited.

Takes months or years to publish due to extensive research, writing, and editing process.

* Peer review is a process in which experts from the same subject field or profession as the author evaluate a manuscript prior to acceptance for publication.

Based on a chart by Kerry Creelman, Univ. of Houston Libraries, which was adapted from content by Kristina De Voe, Temple Univ. Libraries.

Bayou Building 2402, 2700 Bay Area Blvd, Houston, TX 77058-1002